tech

Italy Fines Meta $887 Million Over Android Gallery Photos

News

· tech, news

Meta logo sign outside company headquarters building with a car passing by
Photo by Ümmü Gülsüm Ergin / Pexels · source

Italy's data protection authority fined Meta €805 million ($887 million) on Saturday for pulling photos and videos from Android users' phone galleries into Facebook without specific consent, according to the Associated Press, as reported by ABC News. The authority said the practice violated a European privacy directive written into Italian law.

What feature triggered the fine?

The penalty targets a Facebook feature called "Get suggestions from gallery when browsing Facebook," the AP reported. The tool surfaced photos and videos from a user's phone gallery while they scrolled Facebook, drawing on content the user had not uploaded or shared on the platform.

The Italian Data Protection Authority said the directive at issue protects smartphones as part of a person's private sphere and requires "free and informed consent" before an app can reach into that space, according to the AP account carried by ABC News.

How much is the fine, and who has to pay it?

The €805 million penalty was levied against Meta Platforms Ireland Limited, the AP reported. That entity challenged Italy's jurisdiction to bring the case, according to the regulator's statement.

The authority said the fine equals roughly 0.47% of Meta's global turnover. It also said Meta's "lack of cooperation" during the investigation was a factor in setting the penalty amount, the AP reported. Meta made no immediate comment, according to the wire report.

What did investigators find about how the feature worked?

Investigators determined the gallery-suggestion feature was switched on by default, meaning users did not opt in, according to the authority's findings as relayed by the AP. They also found that Facebook requested access to a phone's gallery through a single permission that covered multiple app functions with different purposes, rather than asking separately for the gallery-suggestion feature.

That bundling is central to the legal violation the authority cited: European privacy rules require consent tied to a specific purpose, not a blanket permission that covers unrelated uses. The regulator's statement, as described by the AP, treats the single-permission design as evidence that users could not have given informed consent to the gallery feature specifically, even if they had granted general photo access to the Facebook app.

What does Meta have to do now?

The authority gave Meta 60 days to disable the feature and to seek separate, specific consent before reintroducing anything like it, the AP reported. Italy has about 20 million Android users, according to the agency's own figure cited in the wire report, meaning the deadline affects a sizable share of the country's smartphone population.

The order does not, based on the available reporting, address whether Meta plans to appeal the fine itself or the jurisdictional challenge already raised by Meta Platforms Ireland Limited. The AP report does not say whether Italy's regulator anticipates a court fight over enforcement.

Has Meta responded to the fine?

Meta had made no immediate comment as of the AP's report Saturday. The wire story does not include a statement from the company addressing the specific findings on default settings or the bundled permission request, nor does it indicate when a response might come.

What does this mean for Facebook users in Italy?

For now, nothing changes for the roughly 20 million Android users the authority referenced, since the 60-day clock for Meta to act was just starting as of the fine's announcement. If Meta complies on the stated timeline, Facebook's Android app would need to turn off the gallery-suggestion feature by default and ask users directly whether they want to enable it, separate from any other permission.

The case adds to a string of European privacy enforcement actions against Meta, though the AP report does not detail prior Italian fines or compare this penalty to other EU actions against the company. The $887 million figure stands as the amount Italy's regulator says Meta owes under the current order, pending any appeal.

The underlying legal theory — that a single permission covering multiple purposes cannot satisfy specific-consent requirements — could matter beyond this one feature if other platforms use similar bundled permissions on Android. The AP report does not say whether Italy's authority is examining other companies on the same grounds.

Disclosure. This article may include affiliate links; we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Legal entity: Pinewood Creations LLC. Smorgi Apps appears only as an affiliate partner in house slots — not as publisher or owner. See our affiliate disclosure.

Questions

How much was Meta fined by Italy?

Italy's data protection authority fined Meta €805 million, or about $887 million, according to the Associated Press.

What did Meta do to trigger the fine?

Meta's Facebook app used a feature that pulled photos and videos from Android users' phone galleries without specific, separate consent, the AP reported.

What must Meta do now?

Italy's regulator gave Meta 60 days to disable the gallery-suggestion feature and obtain separate consent before using it again, per the AP.

Sources

More from HTT News

Briefing

Top stories from the HTT News network by email. Free. No noise.