politics
Burnham Says UK 'Lost More Than It Gained' From Brexit

Prime Minister Andy Burnham is expected to tell London's Lord Mayor's Banquet on Monday that "the Brexit we were given has not worked" and that Britain "has lost more than we have gained" from leaving the European Union, according to BBC News. The speech comes four days before a UK-EU summit at which Burnham is due to sign new agreements covering food, energy and youth mobility.
What is Burnham expected to say in the speech?
Burnham will compare the current Brexit arrangement to "the emperor's new clothes," according to remarks previewed by the BBC: "It's like the emperor's new clothes – where no-one is prepared to say the obvious truth. Well, I say it as I see it. And to be frank, the emperor has nothing on." He will argue that "a needlessly hard Brexit" built barriers for businesses and that the Vote Leave pledge to "take back control" was not delivered, the BBC reports.
What is the UK-EU summit expected to produce?
Friday's summit is built around deals whose substance was set under Burnham's predecessor, Sir Keir Starmer, the BBC reports. The UK and EU have agreed a draft text removing post-Brexit checks on food and agriculture exports between Britain and the bloc. The government says the arrangement will cut costs for businesses and could lower prices for shoppers, per the BBC. Separate draft texts covering emissions trading and a youth travel-and-work scheme have also been circulated to EU member states, though some details remain unresolved.
What are Burnham's three tests for any deal?
Ahead of the summit, Burnham will set out three conditions any agreement must meet, according to the BBC's preview of his remarks. First, it must be consistent with Labour's 2024 general election manifesto commitment that there would be "no return to the single market, the customs union, or freedom of movement." Second, it must improve on the original Brexit deal and move it closer to "what people thought they were voting for in 2016." Third, it must pass what Burnham calls the "Makerfield test" — a reference to voters in his Greater Manchester constituency — by delivering tangible improvements to everyday life.
Burnham will frame the prospective deal as a "win-win" that reflects a "new approach," saying, per the BBC: "Not adversarial. No longer burning bridges. But being constructive and positive — showing that we can come together to confront shared challenges."
What do critics say about the food and agriculture deal?
The arrangement removing checks on food and agricultural exports would align the UK with EU rules without giving Britain a vote on those regulations, according to the BBC, which reports the UK will have a "voice" but no formal vote on EU food rules under the reset. Critics cited by the BBC describe this as making the UK a "rule taker" from Brussels. The Conservative Party has gone further, saying Labour is "dragging us into the European Union via the back door," the BBC reports.
How does this fit the broader UK-EU timeline?
- May 2025 — Sir Keir Starmer, then prime minister, struck the underlying UK-EU deal covering fishing, trade and related areas, according to the BBC.
- Recent weeks — Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband tells the BBC that Burnham will lay out long-term options for the UK-EU relationship after this week's summit.
- Monday, Nov. 16, 2026 — Burnham delivers the Lord Mayor's Banquet speech previewed by the BBC, arguing Brexit has cost Britain more than it has gained.
- Friday — Burnham is due to sign the food, energy and youth mobility agreements at the UK-EU summit, finalizing texts largely negotiated under Starmer.
What happens to the broader UK-EU relationship after the summit?
Burnham has said he wants to examine the "pros and cons" of different long-term options for Britain's relationship with the EU, according to the BBC. Miliband told the BBC that Burnham would set out those options once Friday's summit concludes. At the same time, Burnham has ruled out major changes to the relationship before the next general election, the BBC reports, meaning any broader shift beyond the food, energy and youth mobility deals would not take effect in the current parliamentary term.
The summit itself does not resolve the larger question Burnham's speech raises — whether the current deal, even with the new add-ons, satisfies the manifesto limits Labour campaigned on in 2024. That determination will play out as the signed texts move from draft to implementation and as Burnham's promised post-summit options paper takes shape.
Quotags is A quote-card app first shipped in 2013. Version 2.0 is returning soon — do not install an old binary.
Questions
What did Andy Burnham say about Brexit ahead of the UK-EU summit?
Burnham was expected to say in a Lord Mayor's Banquet speech that "the Brexit we were given has not worked" and that Britain "has lost more than we have gained," according to the BBC.
What are Burnham's three tests for a new UK-EU deal?
The deal must keep no return to the single market, customs union or freedom of movement; it must improve on the original Brexit deal; and it must pass the 'Makerfield test' of delivering tangible benefits to everyday life, per the BBC.
What will be signed at Friday's UK-EU summit?
The BBC reports Burnham is due to sign agreements on food and agriculture checks, energy, and youth mobility, building on terms largely set under former Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer in May 2025.