news
Lindsay Clancy's Retrial Set for March 29 in Children's Deaths

A Massachusetts judge set March 29 as the start date for Lindsay Clancy's retrial on three counts of first-degree murder, NBC News reported Monday, four months after her first trial ended without a verdict. Judge William Sullivan set the date during a status hearing after declining last week to grant the defense's motion to dismiss the charges, clearing the way for a second trial.
What dates has the court set?
By the numbers, according to NBC News:
- March 29 — retrial begins
- March 18 — final pretrial hearing
- ~4 months — time given to both sides to prepare, from the Monday hearing to trial
- Jan. 24, 2023 — date of the deaths
- 3 — number of children killed: Cora, 5; Dawson, 3; and Callan, 8 months
- 9 women, 3 men — composition of the first trial's jury
Clancy is charged with three counts of first-degree murder in the strangulation deaths of her children with exercise bands, NBC News reported. She later threw herself from a bedroom window in what prosecutors and the defense agree was a suicide attempt, leaving her paralyzed and in a wheelchair.
Why did the first trial end without a verdict?
The September trial ended in a mistrial after jurors said a single holdout refused to apply the reasonable-doubt standard, preventing a unanimous verdict, according to NBC News. That juror has since said he "didn't have any doubts," the outlet reported.
What legal terms matter in this case?
- Mistrial: A trial terminated before verdict, here triggered by a deadlocked jury.
- Manifest necessity: The legal threshold prosecutors must meet to justify a mistrial — and therefore a retrial — without violating double-jeopardy protections. Defense attorney Martin Weinberg argued this standard on Nov. 2 in support of the motion to dismiss, per NBC News.
- First-degree murder: Massachusetts' most serious homicide charge, which the prosecution has pursued on all three counts.
- Postpartum psychosis: A severe mental health condition the defense says left Clancy unaware of her actions during the killings.
What are the competing explanations for the killings?
Clancy's defense has argued she was in the grip of postpartum psychosis and did not understand what she was doing, NBC News reported. Prosecutors have countered that she planned the killings in advance and was not in psychosis at the time, according to the outlet. NBC News reported it remains unclear whether either side's arguments will change for the second trial.
What happens next?
- March 18: Final pretrial hearing before the retrial
- March 29: Retrial begins
- Prosecutors, having opted to retry rather than drop or reduce the charges, could still revisit a plea deal, a bench trial, or reduced charges before trial, per the options NBC News said were available after the mistrial
- Defense attorney Kevin Reddington's earlier motion to dismiss the three murder charges was denied by Judge Sullivan, a ruling that stands unless appealed
The case, overseen in Massachusetts Superior Court, will again turn on whether jurors find Clancy was legally unaware of her actions during the killings or had planned them, the central dispute NBC News identified between the defense and prosecution in the first trial.
Artiglio is A coming-soon iPhone chief of staff for briefings and drafts. Not on the App Store yet.
Questions
When does Lindsay Clancy's retrial start?
The retrial is scheduled to begin March 29, with a final pretrial hearing set for March 18, according to NBC News.
Why did Lindsay Clancy's first trial end in a mistrial?
Jurors said a lone holdout refused to apply the reasonable-doubt standard, preventing the nine women and three men on the jury from reaching a unanimous verdict, NBC News reported.
What is Lindsay Clancy charged with?
She faces three counts of first-degree murder in the strangulation deaths of her children, Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, 8 months, according to NBC News.