politics
What We Know About the UK Conversion Practices Bill

Baroness Cass, author of the independent review into gender identity services for young people, told a parliamentary committee on the Draft Conversion Practices Bill that she does not support its current wording, according to the BBC. Asked directly whether she backed the bill as written, she answered "no," the BBC reported.
What did Baroness Cass tell the committee?
Baroness Cass said the bill's wording risked "serious unintended consequences" for parents of children experiencing gender distress and for medical professionals who treat them, the BBC reported. She said increased "polarisation" in debates over gender meant the law could be applied in ways lawmakers did not intend.
"If a young person, for example, has been sexually abused, any discussion about it is going to be incredibly triggering. But if you can't therapeutically work through it without any reference to it, and that's the problem," Baroness Cass said, according to the BBC.
Why did she change her position?
When the government published the draft bill in June, Baroness Cass was quoted in its publicity materials saying she was "pleased" the legislation offered a "clearer definition" of conversion practices than earlier drafts, the BBC reported. She said at the time she looked forward to further scrutiny before the bill became law. Asked by the committee to reconcile that earlier statement with her current opposition, she said she had supported the concept but had not had time to review the bill's final wording in detail, per the BBC account.
What does the bill currently say?
The draft legislation requires that a victim suffer "serious harm to the individual's physical or mental health, or serious alarm or distress to the individual which has a substantial adverse effect on their usual day-to-day activities," the BBC reported. Baroness Cass said that threshold could still allow "vexatious" complaints against therapists working with gender-distressed young people, even when a complaint does not lead to prosecution, citing concerns raised by professionals at NHS Gender Dysphoria Clinics. She also said the bill could expose parents to prosecution — for example, if a parent withheld money from a child over concern it would be spent on a "breast binder or hormones," per the BBC.
What is the government's response?
A government spokesperson said officials welcomed Baroness Cass's comments and would take seriously all evidence presented to the committee, adding that the government wants "to get this ban right," the BBC reported. The bill, promised in Labour's 2024 manifesto, is intended to protect LGBT people in England and Wales from interventions designed to change or suppress sexual orientation or gender identity, according to the BBC.
What happens next?
- The Draft Conversion Practices Bill committee continues taking evidence before recommending any changes to the legislation's wording.
- Ministers have signaled openness to revising language around "serious harm" thresholds based on committee findings, per the BBC.
- Clinicians at NHS Gender Dysphoria Clinics are watching whether final wording addresses concerns about complaints processes affecting therapeutic work, as reported by the BBC.
- Advocacy groups on both sides of the debate are expected to submit further evidence as the committee's review proceeds.
Questions
Does Baroness Cass support the Draft Conversion Practices Bill?
No. She told a parliamentary committee she does not support the bill's current wording, despite earlier publicly welcoming the draft legislation, according to the BBC.
What is Baroness Cass's main concern with the bill?
She said the wording could allow 'vexatious' complaints against therapists and expose parents to prosecution for ordinary parenting decisions, per the BBC.