tech
San Diego — City Council Ends Flock, Smart Streetlight Contracts

San Diego's city council voted Monday evening to terminate the city's contracts with Flock Safety and Ubicquia, ending a surveillance program built around more than 500 automated license-plate-reading cameras and so-called "smart streetlights," according to Ars Technica. The cameras are expected to go dark citywide.
The decision ends a program the city had defended as recently as last month and marks the second time in under a decade that San Diego has installed and then scrapped networked streetlight-camera technology, Ars Technica reported.
What did the council actually vote to end?
The council's action terminates San Diego's agreements with Flock, the license-plate-reader company Ars Technica said carries an estimated valuation of $8.3 billion, and with Ubicquia, which supplied the "smart streetlight" hardware that paired with Flock's software. The combined system covered more than 500 cameras installed across the city in 2023. San Diego Mayor Todd Gloria said in a social media post after the vote that he "respect[s] the Council's decision" and would not veto it, according to Ars Technica.
Why did the council reverse course after backing the program in 2023?
Three years ago, Gloria and other city leaders pushed the council to approve the camera network over objections from the city's own watchdog panel, the San Diego Privacy Advisory Board, which had asked the council to vote the plan down, Ars Technica reported. The political math shifted only last month, when council member Stephen Whitburn withdrew his support, opening a path for a majority to halt the program. At an October press conference, Whitburn said he wanted residents to "feel safe," adding: "If Flock cameras are causing many San Diegans to feel unsafe, then they have lost effectiveness as a public safety tool," per Ars Technica.
Lily Irani, of the Transparent and Responsible Use of Surveillance Technology (TRUST) SD Coalition, told Ars Technica the shift reflected organizing well beyond San Diego: "The national energy creating left and right and center coalitions was the major cause [of the political victory]." Pegah Parsi, a member of the city's Privacy Advisory Board, wrote on LinkedIn that she felt "vindication," according to the outlet.
What does Flock say the city loses by cutting the cameras?
Flock is not characterizing the vote as a neutral policy choice. Andrew Smith, a company spokesperson, told Ars Technica in an email that "when a tool that is actively helping solve violent crimes is removed, public safety moves backward." Smith argued the practical effects would include slower casework, fewer obstacles for organized retail-theft crews, delayed recovery of missing children, and longer waits for victims seeking justice.
Police representatives at Monday's meeting cited figures to support the program's record: a 20 percent decline in vehicle theft since 2023 and 689 stolen vehicles recovered with help from the Flock cameras, according to Ars Technica's account of the meeting. The council's vote to end the contracts nonetheless proceeded over that data.
How does this fit San Diego's earlier streetlight experiment?
This is not San Diego's first attempt at networked streetlight surveillance, nor its first retreat from one. The city previously bought thousands of smart streetlight systems from a different vendor, GE Current, before a prior mayoral administration shut that program down in 2020, Ars Technica reported. Ubicquia later acquired the smart-city platform and, in partnership with Flock and with police backing, proposed the 2023 installation that the council has now also unwound. The repeated cycle — adoption, local pushback, termination — has played out twice in roughly six years.
What happens next for the cameras and the contracts?
Ars Technica's report leaves several operational questions unresolved, including the exact timeline for powering down hardware and whether any data retention or vendor wind-down terms apply. Based on what the council and the companies have said publicly, residents and city watchers have a short list of things to track:
- Shutdown timing: When the more than 500 cameras and streetlight sensors are physically disabled or removed, and who pays for removal.
- Flock's broader footprint: Whether other cities facing similar advocacy pressure, following the pattern described by TRUST SD Coalition's Lily Irani, move to reconsider their own Flock contracts.
- Police data access: What happens to footage and license-plate records already collected under the now-terminated agreements.
- Mayor Gloria's next move: Whether his decision not to veto the council's action shapes how he approaches future surveillance proposals before his term ends.
San Diego's city council did not immediately schedule a follow-up hearing on implementation details, based on the available reporting.
Questions
Why did San Diego end its Flock camera contract?
The city council voted Monday to terminate agreements with Flock and Ubicquia after council member Stephen Whitburn withdrew his support last month, opening a majority to halt the program amid sustained criticism from privacy advocates, according to Ars Technica.
How many cameras are affected by San Diego's decision?
More than 500 cameras tied to the Flock and Ubicquia smart-streetlight program are expected to go dark, Ars Technica reported.
What does Flock say will happen because of the shutdown?
Flock spokesperson Andrew Smith told Ars Technica that removing the cameras will slow case resolution, give retail-theft crews fewer obstacles, and delay recovery of missing children and justice for victims.