politics
What We Know About Trump's Withdrawn FDA and NSF Picks

The White House withdrew its nomination of Heidi Overton to lead the Food and Drug Administration late Tuesday, and the Senate's health committee scrapped a scheduled vote on Jim O'Neill, President Trump's pick to run the National Science Foundation, the following morning, Ars Technica reported.
Who is Heidi Overton, and why was her nomination pulled?
Overton is a top conservative domestic policy aide in the White House who was nominated to be FDA commissioner. Axios reported the withdrawal Tuesday evening, quoting a senior Trump administration official who said Overton "lacks the support on the Hill to move forward with her confirmation," according to Ars Technica's account of that reporting. Senator Bill Cassidy (R-La.), who chairs the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee, said in a social media post that he believed Overton had a "viable confirmation path" but that the nomination was "abandoned" after anti-abortion senators sought commitments from her that she could not give. "The Administration withdrew Dr. Overton rather than make such commitments," Cassidy said, according to Ars Technica.
What happened at Overton's confirmation hearing?
At a September 24 hearing before the HELP Committee, Overton repeatedly declined to answer direct questions from senators in both parties, Ars Technica reported. She would not say how she would handle the FDA's safety review of the abortion pill mifepristone, and she declined to say whether she agreed with Trump's claims that the measles vaccine is "quite lethal" or that children receive vaccine doses the "size of a soda bottle." She also would not say whether Trump could ever be wrong, according to the outlet.
Why does the withdrawal matter for the FDA?
Cassidy said that with limited time remaining, "confirming a permanent FDA Commissioner will fall to Senate Democrats," according to his statement cited by Ars Technica. The HELP Committee had been set to vote on Overton's nomination Wednesday before it was withdrawn.
What happened to the NSF nominee, Jim O'Neill?
Hours after Overton's nomination was pulled, the HELP Committee updated its Wednesday agenda to remove a planned vote on O'Neill, Trump's choice to lead the National Science Foundation, Ars Technica reported. O'Neill, a former Silicon Valley investor and entrepreneur, has drawn criticism for lacking the scientific background typically expected of an NSF director, according to the outlet.
What happens next for these two agencies?
Neither Overton's nor O'Neill's path forward was detailed in the reporting. Based on what Cassidy and administration officials have said publicly, here is what to watch:
- Whether the White House names a new FDA commissioner nominee, and how quickly, given Cassidy's warning that Senate Democrats may now have outsized influence over the process.
- Whether anti-abortion senators who blocked Overton's path spell out publicly what commitments they wanted and from a future nominee.
- Whether the HELP Committee reschedules a vote on O'Neill or whether the White House replaces him, given the criticism over his lack of science credentials.
- Any further statements from Cassidy's committee on timing, since both the FDA and NSF remain without Senate-confirmed, permanent leaders.
HTT News will update this report as the Senate HELP Committee and the White House make further announcements.
mindfulAI Keyboard — An iPhone keyboard that rewrites a draft in a tone you pick. Four free AI actions a day.
Questions
Why did the White House withdraw Heidi Overton's FDA nomination?
A senior administration official told Axios, as cited by Ars Technica, that Overton lacked enough support in the Senate to be confirmed, after anti-abortion senators sought commitments she would not make.
What happened to Jim O'Neill's NSF nomination?
The Senate HELP Committee scrapped a planned Wednesday vote on O'Neill, Trump's pick to lead the National Science Foundation, hours after Overton's withdrawal, according to Ars Technica.