world

Nuremberg Rejected the Just-Following-Orders Defense

News

· world

Rows of wooden courtroom benches facing an empty judges' bench with microphones
Photo by Sergei Gussev / Pexels · source

Judges at Nuremberg decided that a soldier or official who commits a war crime cannot escape punishment simply by saying someone above him gave the order, according to The Washington Post. That ruling, handed down against Nazi defendants, became one of the foundational holdings of modern international criminal law.

What is the just-following-orders defense?

Lawyers call it the "superior orders" defense: the argument that a defendant should not be held criminally liable for an act committed under orders from a military or political superior, because refusing those orders was not realistically possible. Defendants at Nuremberg invoked versions of this argument to explain their roles in Nazi war crimes, according to the Post. The tribunal's answer was that the defense did not excuse the underlying conduct.

Why did the tribunal reject the defense?

The Post's account centers on a single, consequential conclusion: the judges found that following orders does not erase individual responsibility for war crimes. The practical effect was to shift the legal question away from "who gave the order" and toward "what did the person who carried it out actually do." A defendant could still argue that an order affected what he knew or intended, but the tribunal's rejection of the orders defense meant that argument could not by itself clear him of a charge.

This mattered because the alternative — allowing subordinates to point up the chain of command indefinitely — would have made prosecution of atrocities committed by large bureaucracies nearly impossible. If everyone from the lowest clerk to the highest commander could claim he was merely obeying someone else, responsibility would dissolve at every level. The tribunal's ruling, as described by the Post, closed that loophole for the defendants before it.

How does the ruling reach beyond the original case?

The principle did not stay confined to the courtroom where it was first applied. It fed directly into the legal architecture built after World War II for prosecuting war crimes, genocide, and crimes against humanity. Later international tribunals and treaties addressing armed conflict have continued to wrestle with the same underlying problem the Nuremberg judges confronted: how to assign criminal blame inside large, hierarchical organizations where no single person pulls every trigger.

The doctrine also shaped military law more broadly. Armed forces around the world train personnel on the distinction between lawful and unlawful orders, in part because a superior-orders defense does not automatically protect someone who carries out an order that violates the law of armed conflict. The soldier retains an independent duty to assess whether an order is lawful, a duty that traces back to the reasoning the Post attributes to the Nuremberg judges.

Is there any limit to the rule?

Rejecting the superior-orders defense did not mean a tribunal treats every subordinate the same as the commander who issued an order. Context — including how much choice a person actually had, and what he knew about the order's purpose — can still matter to sentencing even when it does not erase guilt. The Post's account does not detail how individual sentences were calibrated, and this piece does not speculate beyond what the source reports: that the defense itself, as a complete bar to conviction, was rejected.

What the ruling firmly settled is the baseline. A defendant cannot say, in effect, "I was only following orders," and expect that statement alone to end the inquiry. The order might explain conduct; it does not excuse a war crime.

Why does this still come up decades later?

Every time a modern war crimes prosecution unfolds — whether before an international court or a domestic military tribunal — the superior-orders question resurfaces in some form. Defense teams still raise versions of it, and prosecutors still have to show why a defendant's individual conduct, not just his position in a hierarchy, supports a conviction. The Nuremberg judges' rejection of the defense, as reported by the Post, remains the reference point lawyers return to when that argument is raised, because it was the moment the principle was first tested against defendants who had direct ties to the machinery of mass atrocity.

The rule's durability comes from its simplicity: an order is not a shield. That one-line conclusion, more than any procedural detail of the original trial, is what later courts have carried forward.

Disclosure. Legal entity: Pinewood Creations LLC. Smorgi Apps appears only as an affiliate partner in house slots — not as publisher or owner. See our affiliate disclosure.

Questions

What is the superior orders defense?

It is the legal argument that a person should not face criminal liability for an act carried out under orders from a superior, according to The Washington Post's account of the Nuremberg tribunal.

Did Nuremberg accept the just-following-orders argument?

No. The judges at Nuremberg rejected it, ruling that following orders does not excuse a war crime, the Post reports.

Sources

More from HTT News

Briefing

Top stories from the HTT News network by email. Free. No noise.