world

What We Know: Myanmar, China Reject ICJ Rohingya Genocide Ruling

News

· world

Rohingya refugees walking along a dirt path near a refugee camp in Bangladesh
Photo by Tony Wu / Pexels · source

Myanmar's government called a landmark genocide ruling by the International Court of Justice "unfair" on Friday, and China said such decisions by the United Nations' top court are "not conducive to the settlement of disputes," according to Al Jazeera. Here is what is known so far and what it means for people affected.

What did the ICJ rule on Thursday?

The ICJ found that Myanmar's military committed state-sponsored genocide against the country's Rohingya minority during a 2017 crackdown, Al Jazeera reported. Judges concluded that security forces carried out mass executions of men and boys, committed widespread rape and sexual violence against Rohingya women, and burned or razed hundreds of villages during so-called "clearance operations." The ruling was the first time in the court's 80-year history that judges determined a state had committed genocide, according to the outlet.

The court also ruled that Myanmar must compensate the Rohingya for the violations, with the amount to be determined later, and must allow the "safe and dignified return" of Rohingya who fled the country as a result of what the ruling called Myanmar's "wrongful acts."

What did Myanmar's government say in response?

Myanmar government spokesperson Khaing Khaing Soe told a news conference on Friday that the military government was the victim of an unjust decision. "Our country was unjustly accused," Soe said, according to Al Jazeera. "This decision is not a unanimous decision by everyone; it is not fair."

Soe's comments pointed to the court's vote count rather than disputing the specific findings about executions, sexual violence or village burnings described in the ruling.

What did China say, and why does it matter?

Chinese foreign ministry spokesperson Guo Jiakun told reporters in Beijing that ICJ rulings of this kind are "not conducive to the settlement of disputes" and said "the international community should make joint efforts in this direction to avoid complicating this issue," Al Jazeera reported.

China is allied with Myanmar's military government. The criticism came a day after China joined the United States and Russia in a statement calling on international bodies such as the ICJ to refrain from what the three countries described as abusing their jurisdiction, according to the outlet.

How did the judges vote, and who is the Chinese judge?

The ICJ's 15 judges split 9-6 in favor of declaring genocide, Al Jazeera reported. One of the court's judges is Chinese and voted in Myanmar's favor on all but one count, according to the outlet. Myanmar's spokesperson cited the lack of a unanimous ruling as evidence the finding was unfair, though a 9-6 majority is sufficient under ICJ procedure to produce a binding decision.

What happens next for Rohingya refugees?

An estimated 700,000 Rohingya fled to Bangladesh during the 2017 crackdown, with others reaching countries including Malaysia, according to Al Jazeera. The ruling requires Myanmar to allow the safe and dignified return of those displaced, but the court did not set a timeline in the reporting available, and Myanmar's government has already rejected the underlying genocide finding.

The compensation amount Myanmar may owe has not yet been determined, Al Jazeera reported, leaving open how and when any payments would reach Rohingya communities still displaced nine years after the crackdown began.

Where do things stand with Malaysia's resettlement plan?

On Friday, Malaysia said it plans to resettle 10,000 Rohingya, according to Al Jazeera's report. The outlet did not provide additional detail in the material reviewed on timing or which agencies would coordinate the resettlement, so residents and advocates should watch Malaysian government channels for further announcements.

For now, the practical effect of Thursday's ruling is legal and diplomatic rather than immediate: Myanmar's military government has publicly rejected the finding, China has criticized the court's role, and the question of compensation remains unresolved. Rohingya families in Bangladesh, Malaysia and elsewhere are left waiting to see whether the ruling leads to concrete steps toward return or payment, or whether it remains contested at the diplomatic level between Naypyidaw, Beijing and The Hague.

Disclosure. Legal entity: Pinewood Creations LLC. Smorgi Apps appears only as an affiliate partner in house slots — not as publisher or owner. See our affiliate disclosure.

Questions

Did the ICJ ruling that Myanmar committed genocide pass unanimously?

No. Al Jazeera reported the court's 15 judges split 9-6 in favor of declaring genocide against Myanmar's Rohingya minority.

What did China say about the ICJ's genocide ruling against Myanmar?

Chinese foreign ministry spokesperson Guo Jiakun said such rulings are 'not conducive to the settlement of disputes,' according to Al Jazeera, a day after China joined the U.S. and Russia in urging bodies like the ICJ to avoid abusing their jurisdiction.

What must Myanmar do under the ICJ ruling?

The ICJ ruled Myanmar must compensate the Rohingya for violations, with the amount to be set later, and must allow the safe and dignified return of Rohingya displaced by the 2017 crackdown, Al Jazeera reported.

Sources

More from HTT News

Briefing

Top stories from the HTT News network by email. Free. No noise.