science
What We Know About the 'Race Realism' Debate in Genetics

Modern genetics does not support claims that racial groups differ innately in intelligence, according to researchers Jonathan R. Goodman and Rebecca Sear, writing for The Conversation and republished by Ars Technica on Nov. 21, 2026. The decision to publish the analysis follows a run of political statements the authors say have revived discredited ideas about race and biology.
What sparked the renewed attention to 'race realism'?
At this year's World Economic Forum meeting in Davos, President Donald Trump said of Somali migrants, "I always say these are low-IQ people," according to the piece. Donald Trump Jr. made a comparable statement about Haitian migrants in 2024, the authors write. The Trump administration has since ended protected status for both Somali and Haitian migrants in the United States, per the article. Goodman and Sear describe these remarks as part of a broader resurgence of "racial views of human nature" in Western politics after roughly 70 years of the ideas being largely sidelined.
What does the genetic evidence actually show?
The authors point to evolutionary biologist Richard Lewontin's work in the 1970s, which found more genetic variation within human groups than between them — meaning socially defined racial categories do not track meaningful genetic difference. Goodman and Sear write that no element of the hereditarian claim — that selection pressures produced higher innate intelligence in white populations — holds up "from the point of view of genetics, evolutionary biology, or psychology."
Who is Nathan Cofnas and why is he named in the piece?
The article identifies Nathan Cofnas as a figure who recently drew public attention by accusing the late Jason Arday of plagiarism. Less noticed, the authors say, is that Cofnas has ties to a network of researchers making what they frame as scientific claims about innate differences in intelligence, criminality, or sexuality across racial groups. Some members of that network hold university affiliations, which Goodman and Sear argue lends an undeserved veneer of legitimacy to the work.
How do these claims end up in academic journals?
Goodman and Sear write that this network's output carries "the appearance of science" while being "methodologically deeply flawed" and failing to engage with rigorous research. Despite that, they say the work is regularly accepted by a small number of mainstream academic journals — a pathway the authors say helps the ideas circulate as though they carry scientific authority.
What real-world effects does the article link to these claims?
The authors tie this body of work, sometimes labeled "race science" or "race realism," to misinformation campaigns on social media and to political movements more broadly, describing the ideas as fuel for what they call far-right propaganda in major democracies. The piece frames the Somali and Haitian remarks, and the subsequent policy changes to migrants' protected status, as a concrete example of where such rhetoric intersects with government action.
The full analysis, including the authors' review of the genetics literature, is available via Ars Technica.
Questions
Does genetics support claims of racial differences in intelligence?
No. Researchers writing in Ars Technica cite decades of genetic research, including Richard Lewontin's 1970s findings, showing more variation within human groups than between them, undercutting hereditarian claims.
Who is Nathan Cofnas?
Cofnas is identified in the Ars Technica piece as someone who accused the late Jason Arday of plagiarism and who has ties to a network publishing disputed claims about race, intelligence, and criminality, according to the article.